Baked Potato Soup Recipe

Heather says,

Ever since I worked at Bennigans, I have adored potato soup. I am fairly certain if it weren’t for snitched rolls and ramekins of baked potato soup I would have wasted away in my late teens. I was sad to see the company recently declare bankruptcy, but take heart the potato soup lives on. This recipe rates just a shade above novice on the difficulty scale. Which, according to my rating system, if you can handle two basic tasks simultaneously and not wander away and get sucked into another activity, you’ve got it in the bag.

Before we get started, let’s talk liquids. Most potato soup recipes call for milk and sour cream, some call for milk and half and half, others call for milk, sour cream, and chicken broth. Substituting chicken broth (or stock) for some, but not all, never all, of the milk lowers the fat content while providing good flavor. I prefer a small dollop of sour cream as a topping rather than stirring a cup full (in place of the half and half in the version below) at the end of cooking, but feel free to experiment.

This recipe is a great use for all those oddly sized potatoes that seem to show up in the large bags. I scrub just enough to fill up a small baking tray, prick each with a fork, and bake for one hour at 400F. When they are done, I place on a baking rack to cool and begin making the soup. While the milk is heating, I peel and mash the potatoes by hand. The peels should slip off quite easily.

Lastly, for those just venturing into the world of cream soups, follow the directions closely the first time, then feel free to experiment. I tend to have a light touch with salt, preferring to allow others to salt to taste at the table.

If you use store bought broth or stock, be very careful with the amount of salt you add, it’s very easy to over-salt in these cases.

How To Make Baked Potato Soup

Baked Potato Soup

Printable recipe below this one

Ingredients:

  • 2 TBSP butter
  • 1 onion finely diced
  • 2 celery ribs + leaves chopped (don’t stress if your ribs are naked or omit completely if you hate celery)
  • 4 cloves garlic minced
  • 1/4 cup flour
  • 5 cups milk, heated (feel free to substitute up to half chicken broth / stock)
  • approximately 5lbs baked potatoes peeled and mashed (Yukon Gold potatoes work well)
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 1/2 tsp ground pepper
  • 4 oz cheddar (or ) grated or cut into small cubes (grate additional cheese for garnish)
  • 4 – 6 slices bacon cooked and roughly chopped (save a little for garnish)
  • 1 cup half and half (or sour cream)

Heat the butter in a heavy pot over medium heat. 

In another pot or the microwave begin heating the milk, not to a simmer or boil, just at least above room temperature.

When it has melted add the onions, stir frequently and reduce the heat to medium-low.

When the onions are soft, add the celery and garlic and sauté for an additional two to three minutes.

Sprinkle the flour and stir well, until the roux is smooth. (Yes, you’ll have celery and onion lumps, watch for small clumps of flour.

Roux with Onion and Celery

Now comes the slightly tricky part. While stirring constantly, begin slowly adding the milk.  At first, you’ll create a thick paste. If you are patient, there should be no lumps. Once all of the initial lumps are gone, you can begin adding the milk or chicken broth in more generous amounts, just be sure it is completely incorporated between additions. Once all the milk has been added, bring the liquid to a simmer, stirring occasionally. As soon as the mixture begins to simmer, reduce the heat to low.

This is when I peel and mash the potatoes, as it can be a little boring.

Stir in the mashed potatoes. Add more broth or milk if the soup gets too thick.

Slowly stir in the cheese, crumbled bacon, salt, and pepper. Allow to heat through, then stir in the half and half or sour cream, stir, and serve immediately.

Enjoy!

Loaded Baked Potato Soup
Write a review
Print
Ingredients
  1. 2 TBSP butter
  2. 1 onion finely diced
  3. 2 celery ribs + leaves chopped (don't stress if your ribs are naked or omit completely if you hate celery)
  4. 4 cloves garlic minced
  5. 1/4 cup flour
  6. 5 cups milk, heated (feel free to substitute up to half chicken broth / stock)
  7. approximately 5lbs baked potatoes peeled and mashed (Yukon Gold potatoes work well)
  8. 1 tsp salt
  9. 1/2 tsp ground pepper
  10. 4 oz cheddar (or ) grated or cut into small cubes (grate additional cheese for garnish)
  11. 4 - 6 slices bacon cooked and roughly chopped (save a little for garnish)
  12. 1 cup half and half (or sour cream)
Instructions
  1. Heat the butter in a heavy pot over medium heat. 
  2. In another pot or the microwave begin heating the milk, not to a simmer or boil, just at least above room temperature.
  3. When it has melted add the onions, stir frequently and reduce the heat to medium-low.
  4. When the onions are soft, add the celery and garlic and sauté for an additional two to three minutes.
  5. Sprinkle the flour and stir well, until the roux is smooth. (Yes, you'll have celery and onion lumps, watch for small clumps of flour.
  6. Now comes the slightly tricky part. While stirring constantly, begin slowly adding the milk.  At first, you'll create a thick paste. If you are patient, there should be no lumps. Once all of the initial lumps are gone, you can begin adding the milk or chicken broth in more generous amounts, just be sure it is completely incorporated between additions. Once all the milk has been added, bring the liquid to a simmer, stirring occasionally. As soon as the mixture begins to simmer, reduce the heat to low.
  7. This is when I peel and mash the potatoes, as it can be a little boring.
  8. Stir in the mashed potatoes. Add more broth or milk if the soup gets too thick.
  9. Slowly stir in the cheese, crumbled bacon, salt, and pepper. Allow to heat through, then stir in the half and half or sour cream, stir, and serve immediately.
Adapted from Bennigan's
Adapted from Bennigan's
Home Ec 101 http://www.home-ec101.com/
Here are some more great potato recipes:

 



33 Comments

  1. Bobbie Laughman on November 27, 2011 at 7:31 pm

    Heather, have you ever made this using leftover mashed potatoes? Seems like it should work.

    • HeatherSolos on November 28, 2011 at 7:09 am

      @Bobbie Laughman I think it would work perfectly, but no I haven’t tried it, I haven’t had any leftover mashed potatoes. Sigh.

  2. Dr Alice on November 27, 2011 at 5:33 pm

    Just made this Heather, it rocked my socks off. A very excellent soup. There is no point in paying astronomical prices for premade baked potato soup when it is so easy and inexpensive to make, and turns out so well.

  3. casey on January 3, 2011 at 12:23 pm

    Can the leftovers be frozen or will the soup separate and be ooky?

    • HeatherSolos on November 28, 2011 at 7:10 am

      It may separate, but if you whisk it back together during a gentle reheating, it should be ok.

  4. Samantha manning on February 28, 2010 at 7:24 pm

    When do you add the bacon? I see you use some as a garnish as the directions say to hold some out for garnish, but is there some added to the soup while cooking?

    • Heather Solos on February 28, 2010 at 7:37 pm

      I've edited the directions. It should be added with the mashed potatoes, cheese, salt and pepper.

  5. Karen on November 16, 2009 at 5:02 pm

    The bacon's probably a garnish. You would add it on top right before eating so it stays crunchy.

  6. Caanan on October 13, 2009 at 2:34 pm

    At what point do you add the bacon? It's on the ingredient list but not in directions.

  7. Menu Monday | Home Ec 101 on October 5, 2009 at 6:32 am

    […]  Loaded baked potato soup, grilled ham and cheese […]

  8. […] Baked potato soup, Spinach salad with candied bacon […]

  9. anjolcake on April 26, 2009 at 7:19 pm

    I can’t wait to try this! My lil’ darlins will love it.

  10. Soup Recipes lover on February 17, 2009 at 1:46 pm

    your soup looks delicious! i didn’t realize how heavy the baked potato soup is until i saw the ingredients in the soup so it will be a treat for me here and there. thanks for sharing this awesome recipe!

  11. Joelene on December 7, 2008 at 12:39 am

    yumm! Sounds great! Would it be okay to use skim, or 1% milk for this to cut some fat?
    Thanks!

  12. Malia on November 22, 2008 at 8:27 pm

    I made this for dinner tonight and it was fabulous! Normally I would omit the celery because I’m not a fan but I had it on hand because I’m making dressing, so I went ahead and added it. It was frowned upon by certain members of the family but they ate “around” it!

    It’s a great recipe and I’ll be making it again!

  13. Musings of a Housewife on November 22, 2008 at 1:24 pm

    I can’t wait to try this!

  14. Janel on November 22, 2008 at 11:07 am

    Oh, that sounds yummy. I LOVE LOVE LOVE potato soup so much.

    Thanks for linking up!

  15. Heather on November 19, 2008 at 8:35 am

    I should note that this is not the official Bennigan’s recipe. However after eating theirs frequently over the course of a year, I would say it is quite similar.

  16. Fabian Perez on November 18, 2008 at 12:13 am

    looks pefect! im not good at cook,but i will try.hope my family will like it .thank you!

  17. Tiffany @ Snapshots of Life on November 17, 2008 at 2:40 pm

    This looks great! I love Bennigan’s Baked Potato Soup, but the one here is not very good- they were even out of the soup one time! This is my first time here, but I will definitely be back. Thanks for sharing!

  18. bill on November 16, 2008 at 3:25 am

    Guess this takes on a new level of importance now that Bennigan’s went bankrupt ? They are reopening, but with a new menu that features “pub fare”. Not sure if the potato soup made the cut or not, so glad to see a good recipe here.
    ==
    Money Saving Tips!

  19. Kendra on November 14, 2008 at 9:37 am

    This was very good. I had a few more potatoes than what was called for so I upped the milk to 7 1/2 cups and adjusted the rest. It was a little thick with my adjustments but I just added a bit of left over chicken broth. Turned out wonderful. Its one of my husbands favorite soups but one I had yet to try to make myself. This recipe is a keeper for sure 🙂

  20. Cookware Lady - Susan on November 9, 2008 at 12:27 pm

    The baked potato soup look so delicious! Lovely blog you got here, got to try this recipe out, my mother love soup but sometime I’m out of idea of what soup to cook.

  21. Lisa- Domestic Accident on November 5, 2008 at 8:47 pm

    It’s supposed to rain here this weekend. Perfect weather for this soup.

  22. Ray Horner on November 5, 2008 at 6:09 pm

    Nice blog! Enjoyed the soup – very tasty and a good version of old Bennigans’ . Instead of a wisk when making roux I use a large semi-flexible plastic fork to wisk the flour. No clumps in the wisk!

  23. Mom of three on November 5, 2008 at 4:35 pm

    i just boil mine until they are done, but still firm and then drain off the water add milk, butter, salt and pepper. This probably tastes better, but mine is faster. And probably lower cal.

    Such a good meal on a cold night. I hear they are coming again so I may make some for dinner. The kids love mashed potatoes, so I can make them and my soup at the same time.

  24. Bryssy on November 5, 2008 at 10:00 am

    I’m gonna have to make this! Thanks for sharing!

  25. Trixie on November 5, 2008 at 9:17 am

    Hello,

    I make a potato soup very similar to this. It is one of my favorites. Very few things say “warm and fuzzy comort food” like hot potato soup topped with all kinds of goodies.

    Thanks for sharing your recipe — I bet the garlic makes it really good.

    Take Care,

    Trixie
    http://farmhomelife.blogspot.com/

  26. marybeth on November 5, 2008 at 9:36 am

    Oh, yum! That looks so good!

  27. mom, again on November 5, 2008 at 9:29 am

    I make potato soup with any leftover cooked potato. If I’m boiling potatoes for one meal, I boil lots more than I need that night so I can make soup in a day or so.

  28. Menu Monday 11/03 : Home Ec 101 on November 5, 2008 at 6:29 am

    […] – Baked potato soup, […]

  29. Kimberly Edwards on November 5, 2008 at 2:16 am

    Mmm…This sounds delicious…

    I’ve never actually had this soup from Bennigan’s, but will look for it if I ever wander in…

    Thanks for this great soup recipe!

    Kimberly 🙂

  30. Vera on November 4, 2008 at 11:06 pm

    Oh, that looks so yummy!

Leave a Comment