More Laundry Soap Is Not Always Better

Dear Home-Ec 101,
I have what is probably a stupid question, but I’d really love an answer. If I have a particularly dirty load of laundry (say, woke up to find the cat had puked on the bed), does it do any good to add extra laundry detergent? In other words, does more detergent=cleaner laundry?
Kickin’ The Cat

does more detergent equal cleaner laundry


WinkIvy says:

laundry supplies guide

Click this picture for more tips!

Actually, no, more laundry detergent is not better, and your clothes will definitely not come cleaner if you add more.  There actually may be more residue left on your clothing after using more detergent than is recommended.  If you have something that is especially dirty and want to get it cleaner, pre-treat with a stain remover, and then wash it in a smaller load than usual, but using the same setting on the washer. (For example, if you usually wash on “large load”, then keep it on large, but wash a small load) The additional water flowing through your clothes should help in getting the item cleaner.

And why is it that cats always puke on the bed? Mine do too! Argh!

Send your domestic questions to


  1. madge on March 30, 2010 at 6:54 pm

    @Margolis, Oxyclean soaking ruined lots of my clothes! Yes it removed or reduced stains but after 6 months or a year I noticed most of my stuff has little holes in it and is falling apart, which they did not over years of washing before. I thought, unlike chlorine bleach, which certainly weakens clothes, the peroxide bleach would not do the same. Well it does, maybe less than chlorine, but IMO find another way to deal with stains.

  2. PS on December 11, 2007 at 4:12 am

    My dog always pukes on my carpet. He never pukes on tile or wood. I don’t know why. Even when he starts to heave I’ll move him to the kitchen and he runs back into the living room.

  3. Rachel on December 10, 2007 at 4:35 pm

    Perhaps more importantly, why do they puke on the bed *while I’m asleep in it?!?*

    Thanks, I’ll keep your tip in mind.

  4. Kathy T. on December 8, 2007 at 12:04 am

    I’ve always been tempted to add more detergent for particularly heinous crud on things. I do wash few things in BIG load when that happens which probably also isn’t good for the machine. Ack pets.

    • Daisy on May 2, 2011 at 8:16 pm

      You have shed a ray of sunshine into the forum. Takhns!

  5. Margolis on December 7, 2007 at 11:49 pm

    I’m going to add the smaller load technique to my stain-fighting repertoire!
    What I usually do is soak the load overnight and add some kind of oxygenating booster (like Oxyclean) with the detergent. Also, hanging laundry in the sun also sanitizes/deodorizes it.

  6. imabug on December 7, 2007 at 10:34 pm

    It’s all some kind of animal conspiracy. It’s the same with dogs. They pick the middle of the night on whatever spot of carpet hasn’t already been thrown up/peed/pooped on to hoark up whatever they weren’t supposed to have eaten a few hours ago.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.