Let’s Make Soup this Fall and Winter

Heather says:

Cooler weather has finally arrived, yes, even in my little corner of the world known as the Low country of South Carolina. I’m finally in the mood for soups, stews, and chilis.  I thought I would put together a round up of all of the warm and hearty, soup goodness that is already available here on Home-Ec101.com. I’d also love for you to take a moment and comment with a link to your favorite soup, stew, or chili recipe. Just be sure to only leave one link per comment or it’ll get kicked into the spam filter. Sorry, but without that, the crazy spambots -those are automated programs that try to take advantage of sites like this one- would have a field day.

homemade soup recipes. warm and hearty, soup goodness


Here we go:














Truth be told, though? The one soup I make more often than any other really doesn’t have a recipe I can link to.

It’s a technique that I have referred to in the past as Mustgo or Garbage Soup. It sounds terrible, but it’s also the one soup I get asked to make more often than any other. The sad thing is, that the Mustgo Soup is always a one off. You see, you make Mustgo or Garbage soup from whatever happens to be in the refrigerator that must be used up or tossed.

Mustgo Soup Recipe

So it’s always a mishmash of vegetables on the verge, leftover meats, usually chicken or beef stock, and herbs and seasonings that complement the seasonings used to prepare the meat. While I find it easy to cook intuitively, it does take a little bit of practice. You have to learn through trial and error and I don’t recommend going too nuts with the flavor combinations in the beginning. While writing this out, I had an idea. I think I ought to explore different flavor families, as an example, what herbs and spices are usually found in Tex Mex cuisine, so you know which ones to reach for when your Mustgo soup is taking advantage of a little leftover taco meat -does that actually ever happen?

Or if your Mustgo soup has leftover pot roast, what herbs and seasonings should you reach for. . .

Are you adventurous enough to experiment with the Mustgo Soup concept? Have you before? How did it turn out?


  1. Jenn on October 14, 2015 at 7:17 pm

    Yes! I’d love to be able to take Mustgo soup to the next level. I have a 4 cup container in the freezer that I fill with soup-worthy ingredients. We’re a family of 3 so it can take a while to get it full enough to make soup. I take a look at what’s there to decide if I’m using beef or chicken bullion. Hot dogs and pork can go either way, otherwise it’s majority rules. 3 cups of water to slightly less than 3 cups worth of bullion (I like Better Than Bullion) and my favorite basic spice blend for seasoning plus some extra garlic powder. I’ve added the occasional odd thing like mashed potatoes, hamburger gravy, and salad. I won’t repeat the salad again but otherwise it all worked out fine.

    Also, for us, Mustgo soup was a gateway food; a simple food used to introduce a child to similar but more complex foods or flavors. I used Mustgo soup to get my daughter accustomed to soup and to a variety of flavors in the form of soup. You’ll never have the same Mustgo soup twice but the flavor can be pretty similar. My daugher is a cautious eater so we frequently use the gateway technique to introduce a new food or flavor.

  2. Michelle on October 13, 2015 at 12:05 pm

    We make Must soup all the time. It has resulted in some of our best and also some of our most terrible soups. They hardly ever come our in the middle. They are either really amazing and can’t really be replicated or really terrible and we aren’t sure we want to eat it. would love to get better at it. It is a fantastic idea for a series 🙂

  3. sarah jane on October 13, 2015 at 10:43 am

    Yes, please. I never know what goes with what and end up using only herbs d’ Provence. On everything.

  4. Nikita on November 2, 2012 at 12:06 pm

    I would be very interested in a series on matching seasonings. You could even have a whole seasonings section. “These are great in x recipe”. Like chicken fried rice for instance… I’ve always been curious about Riceironi’s seasoning but not particularly fond of their rice itself.

  5. Jennifer on October 27, 2012 at 10:42 pm

    Awesome. I make Mustgo Soup all the time, but never thought to give it such a fun name. If anyone in the family asks me what it is, I always respond with, “Name of Primary Ingredient-Name of a Second Ingredient” soup, like “Beef & Potato” or “Chicken & Carrot.”

    Taste-wise, my favorite soup is Loaded Baked-Potato Soup. Ease-of-cooking favorite would probably be mixed beans and ham, since you pretty much just throw everything in a pot and let it simmer for a few hours or so.

    I think a series on flavor ideas is an excellent idea.

  6. Cheryl Smithem on October 27, 2012 at 12:22 pm

    Must go soup is a real favorite in my house. One of my standbys is roasting a whole roasting chicken early in the week or during the weekend with lots of good veggies, then when we’ve enjoyed chicken 2 ways, boil the carcass for stock and other chicken. Strain and chill stock to skim fat; pick chicken from bones, discarding bones and then heating the stock, adding chicken, veggies on hand and spices. Same for meatloaf. I made a killer invention more like Italian Wedding Soup from leftover meatloaf made with the supermarket’s “meatloaf” mix.

    For me, cooking by instinct is the easiest way. I focus more on learning techniques and flavor profiles as you said. Then, I have all the tools in my kit, spices in my pantry, and can go / do what ever I have ingredients to do.

  7. Candis on October 25, 2012 at 10:32 pm

    I always call it “Dump Soup” because I just dump in whatever I have. I find that a bit of leftover spaghetti sauce kicks up the flavor a notch.

  8. Anne on October 24, 2012 at 9:48 pm

    Yes! Please help with herb/flavor families! I’m the least adventurous cooker ever.

  9. michelle on October 24, 2012 at 1:52 pm

    The series on flavor/spice combos is a grea idea!

    I need help with convincing the man of the house to eat soup/stew. Going on 15 years… he’s still convinced that soup is not food. He says it’s not filling. He needs “solid food”. Malarkey, of course, but there you have it.


    My all time favorite “mustgo” soup is the one that comes after Thanksgiving! Omg… delicious!!! http://www.food.com/recipe/turkey-and-dressing-soup-use-up-those-leftovers-soup-190733

  10. osh on October 23, 2012 at 8:54 am

    A series on herbs and spices would be awesome. Along with some notes on using fresh herbs, especially now that the end of the season is here and I’ve gotta do something with the abundance of what’s about ready to die off. My easy one is to turn basil into pesto and freeze it. But what to do about the others?

    Oh, and favorite soup that you listed, definitely the clam chowdah.

  11. Melanie Reed on October 22, 2012 at 11:12 pm

    My two favorite soups are Clam Chowder and Potato Soup. I would love some ideas for additional

  12. Nickolina on October 22, 2012 at 8:24 pm

    This would be a good series. I confess that I, too, generally throw soup together in the same fashion and my husband will ask, “did you follow a recipe?” far too often. Early in our married life I would cook a pound of ground turkey in water with some onion, then use part of the meat in spaghetti (jarred sauce, I know it is low standard but it’s real). The next day I’d combine the leftover spaghetti (we always broke it in short lengths to begin with) and the rest of the meat/broth combo that I’d kept in the frig overnight and taken the fat off of. I’d add a bag of frozen vegetables for soup and that’d be supper with some biscuits. Nothing fancy, but it fed a family of 6 for two meals.

  13. Keter Magick on October 22, 2012 at 7:43 pm

    One thing to mention is that soup, regardless of whether it is of the “mustgo/kitchen-sink” variety or made fresh, is always cheaper to make than any other meal.

    The problem with the “mustgo/kitchen-sink” variety is that there can be no set recipe. It’s always unique because the ingredients available for it are constantly changing. I have probably four basic types: tomatoe-y stew with Italian or Mexican seasoning, chicken/chicken stock with traditional poultry seasonings, cream and/or cheese base, and oriental with soy sauce as a major flavor component.

    My favorite soup is also the fastest – 15 minutes or less – and as far as I know, I originated the recipe (out of desperation). It’s also VERY versatile with lots of potential combinations depending on the add-ins and spicing strategy you select.

    Browned Butter Tomato Soup

    Because this soup is very fast to make and you do not want to overcook it, have all of your ingredients prepped and within reach.

    Put a quarter to half stick of butter in a pot suitable for making stock and brown it. More butter = richer, nuttier flavor. Don’t use too much heat – medium high at the most – and do stir it frequently, to constantly as it nears the finish. This goes fast, and burned butter can’t be salvaged, so don’t wander off!

    Just before the butter is fully browned, add a few tablespoons of baking mix. I use Pamela’s gluten free pancake mix. It will foam up. This actually helps, and seems to do a helpful chemical reaction with the tomato, too. I don’t get quite the same results if I use just flour. Keep stirring until it makes a nice, thick, toasty roux.

    Then add tomato juice. I just use a good quality plain tomato juice, nothing fancy. A less-acid variety will be more mellow flavored when finished. If you’ve got a very acidic tomato juice (looking at you, Dollar General), add just enough molasses or brown sugar to take the edge off without making the soup sweet. Turn down the heat a notch (medium to medium low) and stir occasionally until it simmers. During this reheating time, add some celery seed and any other seasonings you might like. Typically you won’t need to add salt, but go by your taste. I put a list of suggested add-in ingredients below. Mind the textures you add: you don’t want to add a lot of lumps to this soup, as the creamy texture should be the star.

    After the tomato juice has simmered and the add-ins incorporated, add some heavy whipping cream to taste. You can omit it entirely if you like, but I like the combination of browned butter flavor and cream. Turn off the heat and let the flavors blend for a few minutes. You don’t really want to cook the cream, just heat it through and blend it well, and most pots will retain enough heat to do this. Stir a few times just in case there’s a hot spot somewhere – you don’t want it to scorch.

    Ladle into bowls. You can put this soup over the top of a toasted piece of bread (slightly stale is OK, sourdough is awesome…toast while you’re cooking the soup – try browned cheese toast for a variation). Serve plain, or top with a dollop of sour cream, thin rings of green onion/chives, a dusting of ground spices, or shredded cheese.

    Add-in ingredients you might like to experiment with: very finely chopped onions, finely cut fresh basil, white pepper, flavored oil, hot pepper sauce, chipotle pepper, cumin, curry powder, Parmesan cheese (cheap is OK in this), Colby/Jack shreds, sherry or port wine…or use your imagination.

  14. Gator Pam on October 22, 2012 at 3:05 pm

    Jewish Penicillin all the way for me.
    With both matzah balls and noodles!


    I save roasted carcasses from both chicken and turkey and freeze them, then use them to make a large 20-quart stock pot of stock. We’ll have soup for dinner, and I’ll freeze the rest in ice cube trays and then bag the ice cubes to use for future recipes or another meal.

    • Jennifer on October 28, 2012 at 8:17 am

      LOVE that idea of the ice cubes! Thanks!

  15. Kara Nutt on October 22, 2012 at 2:51 pm

    I’d love a series like mustgo soup. I do my own but as I tend toward tex mex cooking anyway, I usually stay in that herb family. I’d love a chance to learn about other herbs and how to pair them up.

    My go to soup is usually a navy bean and ham. I have a nice country picnic ham that I cooked up and chopped up and froze. It’s a VERY salty ham so no so good for slicing and eating, but it’s been great for adding flavor to other things like soup or potatoes. Before I went gluten free my recipe started with a can of guiness beer, dry navy beans, chopped up onion, tablespoon of diced garlic (those jars are just so handy), some of the afore mentioned ham all thrown into the crock pot with enough beef broth added to allow the beans to expand. I never soaked my beans. Now that I’m gluten free I’ve removed the guiness (so sad) and will either just do the broth or if I have it on hand, add in a bottle of gluten free beer. Not quite the same taste but close enough. Let cook on high all day, making sure to add liquid as needed and serve over fresh corn bread (made in the cast iron skillet of course).

  16. D on October 22, 2012 at 2:45 pm

    Years ago when I did daycare two little girls, who where part Asian, wouldn’t eat sandwiches so their Mom sent packaged noodles. They ate the noodles but it didn’t seem like a balanced meal to me. I would add cubed leftovers from our dinner the night before. This became a lunch staple and my kids became fans as well. We even did this at Brownie camp one October.

  17. Carol on October 22, 2012 at 2:41 pm

    My boss loves making me mustgo soup for lunch. I am glad to be fed, but sometimes I would prefer a bowl of cereal! LOL I have my good old standby soups I make, and I am really itching to make a bit pot of beef barely. YUMYY!

  18. Hanna on October 22, 2012 at 2:37 pm

    The winter soup I really love is Cheshire soup. This is the best recipe I’ve found although I usually serve without the sandwiches. http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/recipes/cheshiresoupwithfrie_92118

    The best way I can think of to describe this is leak and potato soup plus. Beautifully filling.

  19. Pamela on October 22, 2012 at 2:34 pm

    Yes! having a series on Mustgo sounds like a Mustdo!!

  20. Windy Taylor on October 22, 2012 at 2:31 pm

    My favorite fall/winter soup is Whole Foods’ Slow Cooker Split Pea Soup (http://wholefoodsmarket.com/recipe/slow-cooker-split-pea-soup). I was not a huge fan of split pea soup until I made this recipe. I think it’s the fresh parsley that puts it over the edge.


    I have definitely made stir fry or pasta sauce from leftover vegetables and other fridge treasures. I call it the “kitchen sink” method. I’ve also done the same thing with pizza.

  21. Melinda on October 22, 2012 at 1:57 pm

    I really need to learn the mustgo technique. I have a part of a smoked pot roast with bbq sauce on it, broccoli, some rinds from some brie, onions, and… I can’t remember what else. I NEED mustgo. 😀

    • Heather Solos on October 22, 2012 at 2:03 pm

      In your case, I’d sweat the onions, chop the broccoli -dare you not to get chopping broccoli in your head- fairly fine, and shred the pot roast. If you have any carrots I’d throw them in with the onions and I’d definitely use beef stock. A can of tomatoes would be awesome -if the sauce was tomato based- and I’d go with whatever the predominant flavors in the roast are. I’d add the brie after adding the stock and adjust the flavors from there. . .

    • Miriam on October 28, 2012 at 6:19 pm

      Yes yes yes!!!!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.